Should We Tell Them? Aug. 2010

Audio File for “Should We Tell Them?”

Dr. Steven Leibo is a professor of international history & politics at the Sage Colleges

“Should We Tell Them?”

There’s nothing like a new school year to reflect on the education teachers are about to impart to another generation of students. And as always the perennial question always remains.

Can what we teachers learned in our youth prepare students not for our past but their future? Sure, for most of the human experience the accumulated wisdom of the past usually worked for the next generation, especially on issues like when and how to plant the next year’s crop.

Though, in our fast moving times there have been transitions that made that less so. Did the generation that grew up just before 1910, really need to teach their young, folks about to spend their lives driving cars, to ride horses? Can the generation that kept themselves informed with T.V. and hard copy newspapers really teach our students how to use 21st century communication tools like twitter and Facebook?

But this fall, the question seems to go far beyond that challenge more common challenge, forcing reflection on those critical issues that few teachers are likely to ever bring up.

Like whether teachers are really going to tell students that we adults, have failed them. Confess that we refused to focus on the emerging core challenges of their lives even when those challenges were shoved in our faces.

That we irresponsibly focused on the gulf oil hemorrhage as if it were an isolated event rather than a warning beacon of how desperate humanity has become to find the petroleum that fuels our lives.

Are we going to tell them that oil, that extraordinarily efficient fossil fuel that gave us such a great run over the last hundred years, is becoming more and more scarce — forcing us to seek out sources in impossibly difficult locations.

Because the petroleum that is easy to find and cheap to process is fast disappearing, which is the only reason anyone was drilling for oil miles below the surface of the Gulf.

Are we going to tell them they are faced either with a continuing world recession or a planet that once fully recovered will see the price of fuel oil resume the dramatically steep climb it was on just before the big crash?

Are we going to confess that we have failed to make the transition away from the very fossil fuels that are destroying life as we know it on the planet. Are we really going to tell them the truth? Are we really going to tell them that the American government, especially its dysfunctional senate failed to pass a climate and energy bill that would allow the United States to take on man made climate change with the seriousness it requires.

Are we going to tell them that the senate failed to pass a climate bill strong enough to allow the ever creative market to move us toward a safer energy landscape. Failed to do so despite how many Americans desperately need all those green energy jobs creative energy legislation would bring.

Failed to do so even as extremes of climate, massive flooding, burning forests– from the flooding waters of Pakistan to the over heated and water starved wheat fields of Russia shouted across the headlines —clear and obvious call signs of our increasingly forbidding planetary climate emergency.

Are we going to tell them that our democracy has become so dysfunctional because too many — especially on the American right — have lost the ability to compromise, the single biggest tool in the quiver of democracy?

Are we going to tell them we’ve been distracted by phony issues designed to win political advantage rather than American success. Trapping ourselves in an environment that undermines centuries of American religious toleration, the very toleration that allowed us to avoid the sectarian strife that has so often destroyed societies from Europe to Asia and the Middle East by fixating on a non issues like the New York’s proposed Islamic center. A community center that is apparently neither a mosque nor anywhere near ground zero.

No, I think we all know the truth. Next week when school opens almost nothing of the real challenges that face our students will even be brought up. And for that, most teachers should be embarrassed

About Steven Leibo

This entry was posted in American Politics, Energy, Human Rights, The Climate Crisis, WAMC Northeast Public Radio Commentaries. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Should We Tell Them? Aug. 2010

  1. Don Walzer says:

    Dear Dr. Leibo,

    I have listened to your commentaries on the radio over the years. When will you stop wasting this precious opportunity to reach so many people with your whining? Please start offering specific facts and possible solutions to problems. Your ranting in generalities offers nothing constructive that might influence positive change. It seems to me that you have a lot of complaints particularly with the “right”. The “left” has just as many shortcoming and are no more eager to be partisan then the “right”. Shouldn’t someone as educated as you be able to take the higher ground and be more objective?

    8/26/10 “Should We Tell Them?”
    “No, I think we all know the truth. Next week when school opens almost nothing of the real challenges that face our students will even be brought up. And for that, most teachers should be embarrassed”
    Public schools: That last bit “And for that, most teachers should be embarrassed” really turns my stomach. When was the last time teachers in public schools were given any choice over what they teach or how they teach in the classroom? Politicians, bureaucrats and folks who stress the need for all things PC have put a strangle hold on what and how teachers teach. Most teachers do a very good job given the resources, time and the general lack of support form parents. Show me a normal kid who gets bad grades and doesn’t have a clue about the issues of the day and I’ll show you a weak parenting situation.
    Higher education: The opportunity for you and your colleague’s to shine. Present hard facts and challenge your student to get involved and come up with real solutions. Try and grow good people who can think for themselves and not be mislead by redirect from what ever direction it may come. You have the power to present the curriculum you chose. Do something positive with it. Stop pointing fingers. It’s too easy and does nothing to bring change.
    Don Walzer

  2. Steven Leibo says:

    Thanks for writing and you’re certainly right that college professors have more flexibility than high school teachers but a lot of them have plenty of room to deal with core issues that face our students such as the energy issue I often discuss. As for specifics, yes you are quite right. I think you will like today’s piece. It’s about people all over the world taking on new energy projects on Oct tenth. It should be a very exciting day. And again, thanks for sending your thoughts. I much appreciate the time you have taken to express them.

    p.s. I did some checking, turns out “whining” about the end of civilization as we know it (and if we keep pushing up the amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere that is what this is about) is allowed.

    Steven A. Leibo Ph.D. Professor of International History & Politics Russell Sage College International Affairs Commentator WAMC Northeast Public Radio District Manager Upstate New York & Vermont The Climate Project http: Leibo’s World Watch Blog

  3. isthereintelligentlifeintheuniverse says:

    I can’t tell my grandchildren.

  4. Dr. Lewis Morrison says:

    Thank you for telling it as it is. I agree that whining is allowed, but even better would be yelling.
    Each of us can use less energy. We can drive slower with our tires filled with air. We can change our thermostats. We can change lightbulbS. We can and should do many things to reduce our carbon foot print.
    But as all of us know who sees a problem clearly is that it will take a significant change in attitude on the part of the government to make the kinds of changes that have to be made to stop the increase in the use of fossil fuels for energy.
    That’s why whining and yelling are good. It lets the politician know that they can vote for the right thing to do and still get reelected because the people who are whining and yelling will support them.
    Keep fighting the fight.
    Dr. Lewis Morrison

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s